Die Trials, Hub Trials, and Splashers 1792-1982

Coin Series
Die Trials, Hub Trials, and Splashers 1792-1982 series coin

About This Series

Production artifacts never intended for circulation, die trials, hub trials, and splashers show how the Mint turned designs into working dies. Die trials are test impressions struck from finished dies — often in soft metals like lead or tin — to verify accuracy and press calibration. Hub trials capture impressions from master hubs (positive design tools) used to sink working dies, documenting an earlier production stage. Splasher is the collectors' name for these one-sided trials, usually in tin or lead and occasionally in cardboard or wax. Judd lists them in Appendix A, from the 1792 Wright quarter trials to a 1989-S commemorative half dollar trial on lead. Materials include lead, tin, white metal, copper, and aluminum. Uniface examples confirm single-die testing, while double-sided pieces indicate paired-die trials. Not all are Mint products: some were struck outside the Mint from dies it sold as scrap in the early 1860s.

Browse by Base(44 bases)

1779 Medal Die Trial
BaseVerified

1779 Medal Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1792 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1792 Die Trial

2 Strike Types
1796 Token Die Trial
BaseVerified

1796 Token Die Trial

1 Strike Type
BaseVerified

1798 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1804 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1804 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1806 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1806 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1815 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1815 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1822 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1822 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
BaseVerified

1836 Die Trial

4 Strike Types
1838 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1838 Die Trial

2 Strike Types
1840 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1840 Die Trial

2 Strike Types
1841-1860 Eagle Die Trials
BaseVerified

1841-1860 Eagle Die Trials

1 Strike Type
1846 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1846 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1849 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1849 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1849 Territorial Die Trials
BaseVerified

1849 Territorial Die Trials

3 Strike Types
1850 Territorial Die Trials
BaseVerified

1850 Territorial Die Trials

BaseVerified

1850-1866 Double Eagle Die Trials

1 Strike Type
1851 Territorial Die Trials
BaseVerified

1851 Territorial Die Trials

BaseVerified

1854 Territorial Die Trials

BaseVerified

1855 Territorial Die Trials

1857 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1857 Die Trial

6 Strike Types
1858 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1858 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1859 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1859 Die Trial

3 Strike Types
1860 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1860 Die Trial

4 Strike Types
1860 Territorial Die Trials
BaseVerified

1860 Territorial Die Trials

1861 Territorial Die Trials
BaseVerified

1861 Territorial Die Trials

1863 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1863 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
BaseVerified

1864 Medal Die Trial

1 Strike Type
BaseVerified

1864 Territorial Die Trial

1867 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1867 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1870 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1870 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
BaseVerified

1871 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
BaseVerified

1874 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1876 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1876 Die Trial

4 Strike Types
1878 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1878 Die Trial

2 Strike Types
1879 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1879 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
BaseVerified

1889 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1919 Medal Die Trial
BaseVerified

1919 Medal Die Trial

1 Strike Type
1920 Die Trial
BaseVerified

1920 Die Trial

2 Strike Types
BaseVerified

1921 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
BaseVerified

1925 Medal Die Trial

2 Strike Types
1933 Medal Die Trial
BaseVerified

1933 Medal Die Trial

1 Strike Type
BaseVerified

1935 Commemorative Die Trials

2 Strike Types
BaseVerified

1964 Die Trial

1 Strike Type
Showing all 44 listings

About the Era

A coin die is a hardened steel tool with the design cut into it in reverse; a hub is the tool, with the design in relief, that presses the design into new dies. Before a die or hub went to work, or while an engraver was still cutting it, the Mint sometimes pressed it into a scrap of soft metal to see the result. Those impressions are die trials and hub trials. Most show only one side, because only one tool was being checked, and collectors call the one-sided pieces splashers. They were usually made in tin, lead or white metal (a tin alloy), and a few were pressed into dampened cardboard or wax; the portrait for the 1892 Columbian half dollar was approved from such a paperboard impression.

The earliest known Mint die trials are the two 1792 Wright quarter trials, one for each side of the quarter pattern that Judd numbers 12 and 13. A Mint memorandum of 1793 records Joseph Wright asking to be paid for two quarter dollar essays cut on David Rittenhouse's orders. Later trials record the work of Christian Gobrecht on the seated Liberty dollar of 1836, Anthony C. Paquet's eagle designs of the late 1850s, George T. Morgan's 1878 and 1879 patterns, and the commemorative and circulating designs of the twentieth century.

Not everything in this tree came from inside the Mint. In the early 1860s the Mint sold old dies as scrap, and collectors such as Joseph J. Mickley and Montroville Dickeson used some of them to strike pieces for sale. The 1806 and 1822 half dollar obverse trials and the 1804 dime obverse trial are of that kind. The tree also holds die trials for medals and for private Gold Rush coiners, which are listed under their own series elsewhere in the catalog.

How They Are Identified

Judd and Pollock numbers. J. Hewitt Judd's United States Pattern Coins lists die trials, hub trials and splashers in Appendix A, numbered by year: J-A1857-7 is the seventh entry for 1857. Andrew Pollock's catalogue gives them numbers in the 3000s for Mint products, the 5000s for private pieces and the 6000s for one-sided strikings made outside the Mint with dies it had scrapped. A few pieces that Judd places in the main pattern list, such as the 1846 quarter eagle in copper (Judd-110a) and the 1876-CC dime trials (Judd-1453a and 1453b), are here because they are trials of regular dies.

Die or hub. A die trial shows the design raised, as on a coin; a hub trial shows it sunk into the metal, because the hub itself stands in relief. The 1860 seated Liberty half dime and dime pieces, the 1876 trade dollar reverse and the 1935 Hudson obverse are hub trials.

One side or two. Most pieces are one-sided, and many are undated because the die was unfinished or only a portrait or eagle was impressed. Their years, shown in brackets on our pages, are the ones Judd or Pollock assign, and the two sometimes disagree.

Metal. The metal is part of the identification. Judd and Taxay called the 1860 hub trials white metal, but they are copper, and the 1836 Capped Bust half dollar trial is lead on an octagonal planchet.

How they differ from patterns and errors. A pattern proposes a new coin or design. A die trial tests a tool, often one already in use, and a mint error is a coin that went wrong in production; Judd keeps the errors in Appendix B. Some pieces sit on the line. The 1798 dollar struck on a scrap of copper may be a trial or a mint error, and the 1846 quarter eagle trial was struck again by half eagle dies.

Key Pieces of the Era

  • 1792: the Wright quarter obverse and reverse trials, J-A1792-1 and 2, in white metal. Each is unique, and the two have been sold together since 1882.
  • 1798: a Draped Bust dollar struck on copper scrap, Judd-25A, found in 2006 by metal detectorists beside the site of the first Mint.
  • 1836: Gobrecht dollar trials, J-A1836-4 and 5 (obverses in white metal) and 8 (the starred reverse in copper), and the lead trial for the reeded edge half dollar, J-A1836-1, struck before LIBERTY was cut on the cap.
  • 1838 to 1840: seated Liberty trials, including a dime obverse with a single star added (J-A1838-1) and a quarter hub trial attributed to Robert Ball Hughes (J-A1840-7).
  • 1857: Anthony C. Paquet's heraldic eagle trials (J-A1857-5, 7, 8 and 9), one of them made for Dr. J. T. Barclay in July 1857 according to Pollock, and his half dollar design, J-A1857-2.
  • 1859 and 1860: the Paquet French head portrait in copper (J-A1859-1), the Type 1 double eagle obverse trial (J-A1859-10), and copper hub trials of the seated half dime and dime (J-A1860-1 and 2).
  • 1876 and 1877: the 1876-CC dime trials in copper and nickel, which uspatterns thinks were made at Philadelphia for a collector, Paquet's trade dollar reverse hub (J-A1876-3) and a lead hub trial of the half union eagle (J-A1877-11).
  • 1878 and 1879: copper trials of Morgan's half eagle pattern (J-A1878-3 and 4) and a white metal reverse for his 1879 dollar pattern (J-A1879-5).
  • 1920 and 1921: lead trials for the Pilgrim half dollar, found in the estates of designer Cyrus E. Dallin and Chief Engraver George T. Morgan, and a lead obverse trial for the Peace dollar on a 45 mm planchet.
  • 1935: a bronze reverse trial for the Arkansas half dollar and obverse hub trials for the Hudson half dollar.
  • 1964: a Kennedy half dollar reverse hub trial in copper with the D mint mark punched in two places, perhaps a test of where the mark should go. Congress passed the Kennedy half dollar bill on December 30, 1963, and Denver struck the first circulation coins on January 30, 1964.

The tree's name runs to 1982, while its pages currently stop at 1964. Judd's Appendix A goes further: J-A1982-1 is a Martha Washington test piece on a copper-plated zinc planchet found in a bag of 1999 cents, and J-A1989-1 is a 1989-S commemorative half dollar obverse trial on lead. Neither has a page yet.

Many trials are held by institutions. The Smithsonian has the brass die and a lead impression of the 1836 dollar trial design, the Mint collection example of the 1836 half dollar trial, and an aluminum Kennedy obverse piece (J-A1964-1). The Library Company of Philadelphia holds examples of the 1836, 1838, 1857 and 1859 trials, and the American Numismatic Society holds the 1806 half dollar die and two of the 1822 trials. White metal and lead pieces are fragile: uspatterns reports that the two known J-A1836-4 trials are breaking up and held together by their paper backing.

Some pieces are disputed. uspatterns does not consider the reverse hub trial dated 1815 a Mint product, the 1798 copper dollar may be a mint error, and a 1920 Pilgrim pair in aluminum (Pollock 7040 and 7050) was declared fake in 1988 and is now thought to be private prototypes.

In Our Catalog

No errors or varieties are listed for Die Trials, Hub Trials, and Splashers 1792-1982 yet. Submit one

FAQ

What is the difference between a die trial and a hub trial?

A die is the working tool that strikes coins, so its design is cut into it and a die trial shows the design raised, as on a coin. A hub is the tool used to sink dies, with the design standing up in relief, so an impression from a hub shows the design sunk into the metal. Both are usually one-sided pieces in a cheap metal.

What is a splasher?

Splasher is the collectors' name for a one-sided die or hub trial, usually in tin or lead, made to check how a design was coming along. A few were pressed into cardboard or wax instead of metal; the obverse of the 1892 Columbian half dollar was approved from an impression in dampened paperboard.

Are die trials patterns or errors?

Neither, strictly. A pattern proposes a design or a coin; a die trial tests a die or hub, often one that was already in use, and an error is a coin that went wrong in production. Judd lists die trials, hub trials and splashers in their own appendix, Appendix A, apart from the patterns and from Appendix B, the mint errors. A few pieces sit on the line, such as the 1846 quarter eagle trial in copper that was struck a second time by half eagle dies.

Were all of these made by the Mint?

No. Some were struck outside the Mint from old dies the Mint had sold as scrap, such as the 1806 and 1822 half dollar and 1804 dime obverse trials, and uspatterns does not think the hub trial dated 1815 is a Mint product. The tree also holds a few die trials for medals and for private gold coiners of the Gold Rush.

Why are some of these dated in brackets, like (1836)?

Many trials carry no date because the die was unfinished or only the portrait or eagle was impressed. The bracketed year is the one Judd or Pollock assigns, and the two references sometimes disagree; the 1859 double eagle obverse trial is dated 1850 in Judd and 1859 in Pollock.

↑ Back to the coins: every year, mint, variety and error

Explore Other Denominations

Collector Essentials

Tools and references for building and protecting your coin collection.

As an Amazon Associate, NumisDex earns from qualifying purchases.