Stella Four Dollars 1879-1880

Coin Series
Stella Four Dollars 1879-1880 series coin

About This Series

Proposed by John A. Kasson, a former congressman then serving as U.S. minister to Austria-Hungary, as an international trade coin, the four-dollar Stella was calculated to align with major European currencies — the Austrian 8-florin, French 20-franc, and Italian 20-lira — facilitating commerce without constant conversion. Charles Barber designed the Flowing Hair type featuring Liberty with loosely draped hair, while George T. Morgan created the Coiled Hair variant. Struck in gold at 7 grams in a metric-friendly alloy of 85.71% gold, 4.29% silver, and 10% copper, the Stella was produced exclusively as a pattern. About 425 Flowing Hair pieces dated 1879 were struck, most of them in 1880 for members of Congress; published figures for the Coiled Hair run from about 20 down to 12 for 1879 and 10 or 8 for 1880. NGC has traced nine different 1880 Coiled Hair examples. Congress ultimately rejected the denomination, leaving the Stella as a tantalizing glimpse of international monetary cooperation that might have been.

Series Information

Designer
Charles E. Barber / George T. Morgan
Composition
85.7% Gold, 4.3% Silver, 10% Copper
Weight
7g
Diameter
22mm

Browse by Base(2 bases)

Showing all 2 listings

Strike Types & Varieties(4)

History

The Latin Monetary Union of France, Switzerland and their partners used the 20-franc gold piece as its standard coin. John A. Kasson, who had once chaired the House coinage committee and was then the American minister to Austria-Hungary, proposed in 1879 that the United States strike a gold coin close enough to it in weight to pass alongside it. The result was a four dollar piece with its metal content stated in grams.

The match was never exact. The Stella weighed 7 grams to the 20-franc coin's 6.45, held 6 grams of gold against 5.81, and was made .857 fine rather than .900. Exchange rates moved in any case, and Congress declined to adopt the coin. Some researchers, among them Mark Borckardt, doubt that the Mint ever made planchets in the stated gold, silver and copper alloy, and suggest it cut down ordinary half eagle blanks instead.

Two obverses were made, one by Chief Engraver Charles E. Barber and one by assistant engraver George T. Morgan, with a reverse by Barber, and both were struck in 1879 and 1880. The Mint struck the first 40 sets of these patterns on a medal press in January 1880, and members of Congress asked for 100 more sets that March. Several hundred more 1879 Flowing Hair coins followed and were sold to congressmen at cost, and some of them were later seen worn as jewelry around Washington. The Coiled Hair coins and the 1880 Flowing Hair were made in far smaller numbers and were not widely known to collectors until Edgar H. Adams wrote about them early in the 20th century.

The Mint also struck the designs in copper, aluminum and white metal, which are listed with the 1879 and 1880 four dollar patterns, and in 1879 it made five $20 pieces on the same metric plan, the quintuple stellas.

How to Identify It

Obverse. Liberty's head, in one of two styles (see the table). Around her, separated by stars, runs the inscription 6 G .3 S .7 C 7 GRAMS, meaning 6 grams of gold, 0.3 gram of silver and 0.7 gram of copper in a 7-gram coin. The date is below.

Reverse. A large five-pointed star is inscribed ONE STELLA and 400 CENTS. E PLURIBUS UNUM is above it and the experimental Latin motto DEO EST GLORIA below. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA runs around the top and FOUR DOL. around the bottom, so the coin states its value three ways.

No mint mark. Every Stella was struck at Philadelphia, as a proof.

Telling the designs apart.

DesignDesignerLiberty's hair18791880
Flowing HairCharles E. Barberflowing, not coiled425 (NGC, USA Coin Book, Wikipedia)15 (NGC) or 17 (USA Coin Book)
Coiled HairGeorge T. Morgancoiled into a bun held by a band inscribed LIBERTYabout 20 struck (CoinWeek); 15 (NGC); 12 (USA Coin Book)10 (NGC) or 8 (USA Coin Book)

Things that cause confusion.

  • Gold, copper or aluminum. The same dies struck pieces in other metals, some of them later gilt. A gilt copper or aluminum piece can look like gold, so the metal matters as much as the design.
  • The doubled D. NGC reports that the D in UNITED is doubled on every 1879 and 1880 Stella it has examined, so that doubling is a feature of the reverse die, not an error on one coin.
  • Who designed the Coiled Hair. It is credited to Morgan, though Roger Burdette has suggested that Barber may have reworked Morgan's design for the coin (search).

Key Dates and Varieties

  • 1879 Flowing Hair (Judd-1635 (search)): 425 struck, most of them in 1880 for members of Congress.
  • 1879 Coiled Hair (Judd-1638 (search)): CoinWeek says about 20 were struck and 13 to 15 survive; NGC gives 15 and USA Coin Book 12.
  • 1880 Flowing Hair: NGC gives 15 struck and USA Coin Book 17.
  • 1880 Coiled Hair: NGC gives 10 struck and USA Coin Book 8. NGC has traced nine different examples.

In Our Catalog

No errors or varieties are listed for Stella Four Dollars 1879-1880 yet. Submit one

Mintages

Stella Four Dollars 1879-1880 mintages by year and mint, taken from each coin's page in our catalog. Each figure opens that coin's page, which lists its varieties and errors. A dash means no figure was recorded. Where one issue was struck in more than one type, each type is listed.

Composition and Gold Content

  • Composition (stated): 6 grams gold, 0.3 gram silver, 0.7 gram copper (about 85.7% gold, 4.3% silver, 10% copper)
  • Weight: 7 grams
  • Gold content: about 0.1935 troy ounce (NGC)
  • Diameter: 22 mm
  • Edge: reeded
  • Designers: Charles E. Barber (Flowing Hair obverse and the reverse); George T. Morgan (Coiled Hair obverse)

FAQ

What is a Stella?

A four dollar gold coin the Mint struck as a pattern in 1879 and 1880. It was meant to hold about as much gold as the 20-franc piece of France and its partners in the Latin Monetary Union, so that it could pass in European trade. Congress never adopted it, so no Stella was ever issued for circulation.

Is the Stella a pattern or a regular coin?

A pattern. Every Stella was struck at Philadelphia with a proof finish for officials and collectors, never for circulation. Many catalogs nevertheless list the gold Stellas with the regular gold coins, the way they treat the Gobrecht dollars.

What is the difference between the Flowing Hair and Coiled Hair Stellas?

The obverse. Charles E. Barber's Flowing Hair design shows Liberty with flowing hair; George T. Morgan's Coiled Hair design has it coiled into a bun held by a band inscribed LIBERTY. Both use Barber's reverse, and both were struck in 1879 and in 1880.

How many Stellas were made?

NGC, USA Coin Book and Wikipedia all give 425 for the 1879 Flowing Hair, most of them struck early in 1880 for members of Congress. The other three are counted in the tens, and the published figures differ, from about 20 to 12 for the 1879 Coiled Hair, 17 or 15 for the 1880 Flowing Hair, and 10 or 8 for the 1880 Coiled Hair.

What do the inscriptions on a Stella mean?

The obverse ring reads 6 G .3 S .7 C 7 GRAMS, the coin's intended metric make-up of 6 grams of gold, 0.3 gram of silver and 0.7 gram of copper. The reverse states the value three times, as ONE STELLA and 400 CENTS on the star and FOUR DOL. at the bottom, with E PLURIBUS UNUM and DEO EST GLORIA as mottoes around the star.

↑ Back to the coins: every year, mint, variety and error

Explore Other Denominations

Collector Essentials

Tools and references for building and protecting your coin collection.

As an Amazon Associate, NumisDex earns from qualifying purchases.