2005 (P) Minnesota Satin Finish State Quarter - Doubled Die Reverse DDR-054
Error
Attribution
Discovered by
James Wiles
Verified by
VarietyVista
Original Research
Description
The 2005 Minnesota DDR-054 — widely known as the "Extra Tree" — exhibits strong doubled die spread creating a clearly visible additional tree to the right of the third tree on the reverse, a doubling which drew widespread media attention and introduced thousands of new collectors to variety hunting. Cataloged by VarietyVista with UVC-1509 and DMR-057, this Early Die State variety appears on SMS (Satin Mint Set) finish coins, meaning examples can be found in 2005 official Mint Sets with the distinctive satin finish produced from 2005 to 2010. Charles Vickers' Minnesota reverse depicts a loon on a lake framed by evergreen trees, and the doubled die created an unmistakable phantom tree visible to the naked eye on strong examples. Struck on copper-nickel clad at 24.26 mm with SMS finish. Look right of the third tree for the extra tree.
Die Markers
- UVC-1509
- DMR-057
- Stage A:
- Reverse and Obverse are EDS
- Stage B:
- MDS (unconfirmed)
- Stage C:
- LDS (unconfirmed)
External References
Additional Notes
SMS. Can be found in Mint Sets.
Community & Reference
Related Errors
More Doubled Die Reverse Errors

1883 Doubled Die Reverse WDDR-001
Doubled Die Reverse
1889 Doubled Die Reverse WDDR-001
Doubled Die Reverse
1862 Indian Head Cent Doubled Die Reverse FS-801 Snow-5
Doubled Die Reverse
1862 Indian Head Cent Doubled Die Reverse FS-802 Snow-6
Doubled Die Reverse
1863 Indian Head Cent Doubled Die Reverse FS-801 Snow-10
Doubled Die ReverseCollector Essentials
Tools for examining and preserving error coins and die varieties.
10x-20x Jeweler's Loupe
Essential for examining die varieties, doubled dies, and RPMs
Cherry Picker's Guide
The definitive reference for U.S. error coins and die varieties
2x2 Coin Flips & Holders
Protect and organize your finds with archival-quality holders
USB Digital Microscope
Capture detailed images for documentation and community submissions
As an Amazon Associate, NumisDex earns from qualifying purchases.




