1881 Proof Hawaiian Fantasy Strike - Five Cent, Nickel

Coin Details

Auction Record

$5,760 PR64 11-18-2020 Stack's Bowers

Description

The 1881 Proof Hawaii Fantasy Strike Nickel is a later restrike or fantasy production using dies related to the original 1881 Hawaiian nickel pattern. The distinction between pattern (the original Mint production) and fantasy strike (a later, unofficial production) is critical in Hawaiian numismatics, where numerous fantasy pieces were produced in the late 19th and early 20th centuries using original or copied dies. Fantasy strikes of Hawaiian patterns were produced by various parties who had access to original dies or created copy dies. These pieces were made primarily for sale to collectors rather than as any form of monetary proposal. While they lack the official status of the original patterns, they are nonetheless collected as interesting numismatic artifacts that illuminate the market for Hawaiian collectibles during the period. The proof finish on this fantasy strike indicates careful production with polished dies and planchets, resulting in mirror-like fields and sharp design details. These characteristics suggest production by a skilled die maker or mint facility rather than a crude reproduction.

Rarity Notes

Rare. Fantasy strikes of the 1881 nickel exist in small numbers, though more common than the original patterns. PCGS #510974.

Cross References

PCGS #510974; cf. Medcalf-Russell 2CN-2 (for original)