1858 Flying Eagle Cent - Small Letters - RCD-1c-1858-01 Retained Cud
Error
Attribution
Discovered by
Thomas Johnson
Verified by
Cuds on Coins
Original Research
Description
Cataloged by Cuds on Coins, RCD-1c-1858-01 records a die rim failure on an 1858 Flying Eagle cent with the Small Letters obverse. The Flying Eagle cent, designed by James B. Longacre and produced from 1857 to 1858 (with limited 1856 pattern strikings), inaugurated the small cent era in American coinage — replacing the large copper cents that had been produced since 1793 with a smaller, lighter coin that used a copper-nickel alloy. The "Small Letters" designation refers to the obverse lettering: the letters AM of AMERICA stand apart, as they do on this coin, while on the Large Letters they touch. Philadelphia struck approximately 24.6 million Flying Eagle cents in 1858, the denomination's final year before it was replaced by James B. Longacre's Indian Head cent design in 1859. The copper-nickel composition (88% copper, 12% nickel) was harder than the pure copper used for large cents, creating greater die stress during production and contributing to the die failure that this retained cud documents. The retained cud mechanism — rim fracture without separation of the broken fragment — produces a raised displacement along the rim with the crack boundary preserved as a visible line on struck coins. Cuds on Coins lists no cross-reference for it.
External References
Community & Reference
Related Errors

1858 Flying Eagle Cent (Small Letters) Reverse Rim Cud (12 to 4 o'clock)
Rim Cud
1858 Flying Eagle Cent (Small Letters) Reverse Rim Cud (2 to 5 o'clock)
Rim Cud
1858 Flying Eagle Cent (Small Letters) Reverse Rim Cud (6 to 9 o'clock)
Rim Cud
1858 Flying Eagle Cent (Small Letters) Reverse Rim Cud (7 to 1 o'clock)
Rim Cud
1858 Flying Eagle Cent (Small Letters) Spiked Head
Die CrackMore Retained Cud Errors
Collector Essentials
Tools for examining and preserving error coins and die varieties.
10x-20x Jeweler's Loupe
Essential for examining die varieties, doubled dies, and RPMs
Cherry Picker's Guide
The definitive reference for U.S. error coins and die varieties
2x2 Coin Flips & Holders
Protect and organize your finds with archival-quality holders
USB Digital Microscope
Capture detailed images for documentation and community submissions
As an Amazon Associate, NumisDex earns from qualifying purchases.




