1834 C. Bechtler Five Dollar Gold Piece - 140 Grains, 20 Carats, Rutherford, Plain Edge

Coin Details

Auction Record

Description

This C. Bechtler five-dollar piece of 140 grains and 20 carats (Kagin K-17) has the reverse 5 DOLLARS. * C:BECHTLER.AT RUTHERFORD and a plain edge. Christopher Bechtler, a goldsmith and watchmaker born in Pforzheim in Baden in 1782, came to the United States in 1829 and set up a private mint in Rutherford County, North Carolina (Wikipedia); Greysheet dates his first coins to June 1831. The pieces carry no year of issue. They name the maker and state their weight in grains and their fineness in carats, and the Mint found C. Bechtler five-dollar pieces between one and six percent below their stated value, three percent on average, and his dollars worth 95 to 97 cents (Eckfeldt and Du Bois, 1850). After the federal gold standard was lowered in 1834 he cut his weights to 140 grains at 20 carats, 134 at 21 or 128 at 22 for five dollars and 28 grains for a dollar; several five-dollar dies carry the date AUGUST 1. 1834., the day the new federal standard took effect, and kept it on later issues, so the date does not give the year of striking (Dickeson; Greysheet). Greysheet dates it to about 1834-1837 and reports that its obverse, dated AUGUST 1. 1834., served also for the transitional piece, K-16 and K-18, and its reverse for two GEORGIA GOLD obverses. Catalogue numbers: K-17. PCGS number 10091.

Rarity Notes

R-4 (Greysheet)

Cross References

K-17