"1814" Bronze Medal J-MI-17, Gen. James Miller Modern Restrike

Coin Details

Description

This modern restrike of the Julian MI-17 military medal reproduces the Congressional Gold Medal honoring Brigadier General James Miller for his valor at Lundy's Lane during the War of 1812. The original dies were engraved by Moritz Furst at 65mm diameter, with the reverse battle scene based on Thomas Sully's artwork. Congress authorized the medal on November 3, 1814, though it was not struck until 1824. Modern restrikes (ca. 1950s-1970s and later) were struck from copy dies rather than the original Furst dies, showing noticeable loss of sharpness from excessive sandblasting and distinctly grainy surfaces. They are composed of bronze alloy (90% copper, 10% zinc) rather than the pure copper of early strikes. The obverse features Miller's portrait with his legendary "I'LL TRY" response to General Jacob Brown's order to capture British guns at Lundy's Lane — a phrase that became the motto of the 5th U.S. Infantry. Miller's bayonet charge captured the entire British battery and turned the battle.

Rarity Notes

Modern restrike from copy dies, distinguished from originals by bronze alloy composition (specific gravity ~8.5 vs. ~8.9 for pure copper originals), sandblasted matte finish, and reduced die detail. Less desirable than early strikes or 19th-century restrikes but affordable for type collectors.

Cross References

Julian MI-17; PCGS #784649; U.S. Mint Medal #414; Modern restrike from copy dies